Case Study - Tinnitus
"It's interfering with my ability to pick out words clearly," said my 44-year-old patient. "Andrea" was commenting on piercing tinnitus in both ears that she had been experiencing for many years. She rated its intensity at 8 on a scale of 0 to 10. She also reported pain in her neck and jaw which she scored at 4. She was treated with laser therapy and acupuncture.
Following the first treatment, neck pain was completely alleviated and tinnitus was reduced by half. Following the second treatment, all tinnitus in the left ear and jaw pain on the left side were totally resolved. Following her fourth and last visit, she scored the remaining tinnitus in the right ear at 2 and jaw pain on the right side at 1. She observed that her comprehension of conversation had improved greatly and noted, "It's amazing how quiet everything seems."
A Specialty in Ear Disorders?
A growing number of clinics and practitioners worldwide are choosing to specialize in disorders of the ear, including tinnitus, hearing loss and Menière's disease, with laser therapy as the leading modality. Laser therapy has had spectacular reviews in this area. Lutz Wilden writes, "Even serious impairments such as the most excruciating cases of tinnitus, dysacusia, morbus Menière and bradyacusia can be considerably alleviated and even healed with the aid of modern light technology and the corresponding medical management."1
What is Tinnitus?
Tinnitus is the perception of sound without an external cause. It may affect as many as 37 million adults in the United States.2 Because of the high complexity of inner-ear structures and nerve pathways, it may be impossible to pinpoint any single cause for someone's tinnitus. Yet three main sources of tinnitus have been proposed: muscular tension damage to the cochlea and brain injury.
The last has no known treatment, but the first two have been documented to respond positively to laser light at low intensity. Determining whether tinnitus is due to muscular tension or cochlear damage may allow one to choose the correct laser approach.
Can your patient change the pitch or intensity of the tinnitus by yawning or moving the head? If the answer is yes, then laser therapy to relax muscle tension in the neck, shoulder or jaw may be all that is needed. Knowing that "Andrea" was able to change the pitch of the sound by moving her head up and down was a strong clue that muscle tension was a big part of the problem.
It is not always that easy. Muscular tension may be the body's legitimate response to a deeper problem that must be identified and addressed. Frequently, the culprit is dental malocclusion.3 If contact between the front teeth of the upper and lower jaws is too strong, the mandible may be forced backward, placing stress on the temporomandibular joint, and tinnitus and/or pain may result. In this case, referral to a dentist to adjust the bite will be necessary.4
The cochlea is an important sound- processing structure shaped like a snail shell deep in the inner ear. Acoustic trauma may damage delicate hair cells within the cochlea and the fine nerves interconnected with them. These nerves may then send impulses to the brain which it interprets as sound. Cochlear damage frequently is the result of acoustic trauma.
Administering treatment directly into the ear is the preferred method of laser therapy in this kind of tinnitus. It has received great reviews. It is strongly advised that both ears be treated simultaneously in order to prevent vertigo. Irradiation directly into the ear should not be attempted with a laser single probe, but rather with devices designed specifically for this purpose with twin laser diodes, one for each ear.
What can patients expect? Lutz Wilden writes, "First the patients experience an amelioration of their hearing capacity. Then the symptoms sensation of pressure in the ear and vertigo improve and finally the ringing in the ears (tinnitus) changes its property; having first become unsteady in volume, tone quality and frequency (which often gets higher and higher) and more easily assignable to corresponding stressors, it gradually thins down and recedes further and further into the background, until it eventually disappears for good."5
Case Study - Menière's Disease, Hearing Loss
"Lottie," a 76-year-old female, was diagnosed with Menière's disease with a chief complaint of severe, sudden episodes of vertigo (once while driving). Tinnitus and a sense of pressure were greater on the left side, and she reported deafness in that ear. Low-level laser therapy was administered into the acoustic openings in both ears simultaneously. Prior to the second treatment she said, "I have had almost no dizziness." Before her third session she noted, "I've had no attacks." After her fifth session, "It's a miracle. Everything feels great." During her 15th visit, she reported that she could hear in the left ear once again.
How effective Is This Treatment?
In a study of 348 patients, Lutz Wilden reported that the hearing capacity increased by 20.6 percent on average. The level of improvement correlated with the patients' age and the duration of the condition.6 In a study by Miroslav Prochazka, more than half of all patients reported significant and/or total relief of tinnitus (30.6 + 22.2 = 52.8 percent).7
Bioelectromagnetic therapy8 is another energy-based treatment reported to have significant positive effects in tinnitus and which may complement laser treatment. In a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of 58 patients with chronic tinnitus, active and placebo devices were randomly assigned. Roland, et al., concluded, "Forty-five percent of the patients who completed the trial were improved by the active device, but only 9 percent by placebo."9 Bogomilskii, et al., treated 105 children with hearing loss using low-frequency electromagnetic fields and reported, "The method was found highly effective and valuable for wide practice."10
Laser therapy has biostimulative and regenerative effects and has been documented to improve hearing, tinnitus and Menière's disease. To view what researchers have written, visit www.healinglightseminars.com. Click on these tabs in the following order: "Laser Research Library;" "Ear - Menière's Disease, Tinnitus;" "Bioelectromagnetic Research Library;" "Hearing Loss - Hypoacusis" and "Tinnitus."
Hearing loss is second only to low back pain as the most common physical disability in the U.S.11 Anyone interested in treating ear disorders may wish to give serious consideration to developing this as a personal specialty. Much more information will need to be acquired than has been presented in this article. Yet once one has the knowledge, administering laser therapy for ear disorders may be the least labor-intensive of all specialties one might choose.
Choosing a specialty can be a highly profitable and satisfying way to grow one's practice. Treating ear disorders is just one area among many with great potential to be explored. Laser and bio-electromagnetic therapies have been documented to help in a wide variety of conditions. Including these therapies within your practice may enhance what you are already doing. They also might open new windows of opportunity. What specialty would be personally and financially most rewarding for you and of service to your community? What kinds of patients would you like to attract and treat?
- Reference available here.
- Tuner J. Low-level laser therapy of tinnitus - a case for the dentist? Swedish Laser Medical Society. Available at: www.laser.nu.
- Tuner J. In an oral presentation on laser therapy in tinnitus sponsored by the Swedish Laser Medical Society, June 4, 2007. Stockholm, Sweden.
- Wilden L. Report on more than eight years of low level laser therapy of chronic inner ear diseases. The IXX Annual Meeting of the American Society for Laser Medicine and Surgery, Lake Buena Vista, Fla., April 16-18, 1999. Lasers Surg Med. 1999; 24 (Suppl 11).
- Prochazka M. The Role of LLLT in Treatment of Tinnitus. Laser Partner. Available here.
- Bioelectromagnetic therapy is the application of electromagnetic fields to treat and prevent disease. It has been practiced in medicine for at least 60 years - and perhaps as long as we have been able to send current through wire. Thousands of studies have been performed with benefits reported in a wide variety of conditions. Modern bioelectromagnetic therapy is standard practice in Eastern Europe as a primary or adjunctive therapy to address a great many conditions.
- Roland NJ, Hughes JB, Daley MB, et al. Electromagnetic stimulation as a treatment of tinnitus: A pilot study. Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci, Aug 1993;18(4):278-81.
- Bogomil'skii MR, Sapozhnikov I, Zaslavskii A, Tarutin NP. The treatment of hypoacusis in children by using a pulsed low-frequency electromagnetic field. Vestn Otorinolaringol, Nov-Dec 1996;6:23-6.
- Reference available here.
Click here for previous articles by David Rindge, DOM, LAc, RN.